• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Setauket Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers

Setauket Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers is a beloved gem nestled in East Setauket, NY, known for its exceptional food and warm service. From delectable breakfast sandwiches to hearty family-style meals, every dish showcases a commitment to quality and flavor. The deli thrives on community connections and offers catering for special events, making it a go-to for locals. Whether you’re enjoying a chef salad or indulging in their acclaimed fried chicken dinner, each bite reflects craftsmanship and passion. With outdoor seating and a welcoming atmosphere, Setauket Gourmet is not just a deli; it's a cherished gathering place for families and friends.

Setauket Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers: Reviews & Ratings

Jules M.
Jules M.

Great food and amazing service. Best egg sandwiches in town!!! Workers are always very kind and attentive

Emma J.
Emma J.

Hands down best deli in Setauket / Stony Brook. The food is great and the people are so kind - I always hit this spot when I'm in town.

Jeanine M.
Jeanine M.

Catered our Christmas dinner from Setauket Gourmet. Everything was delicious. We cater from here for all our events. Great service.

Glenn S.
Glenn S.

So, I'm in Setauket and it's lunchtime. I don't want to endure the logjam that is Se-Port Deli's order queue... I decide to try this deli which is right next to Mario's. There's a very short line today... I order ham& swiss on a hero- plain- nothing on it- just meat, cheese & bread. That' s me. Easy-Peasy. Boom -it's done and I eat half of it in my car with coffee. Five minutes, I'm done. That was pretty freaky tasty. And I still have half to take home. It was like ten bucks, relatively modest for these times. I was delighted with my choices & I'm gonna come back here again.

Fran G.
Fran G.

This deli does excellent catering. We just catered our first party with setauket gourmet deli. The food was delicious. Delivered right on time. We also had a server from this deli for our party and lidia was great. We definitely will plan our next party using setauket gourmet deli again. The staff was exceptional. Thanks for making our party a big success.

Bob D.
Bob D.

I have been coming here for many years. Always a good experience no matter what time of day. I just had a Protein Bowl for lunch. It was excellent! Kudos to Billy for making this and other meals for me. He always greets me by name and goes out of his way to make sure my meal is prepared on time and the way I like it. Thank you Billy! I encourage you to check them out if you have not done so already. You will not be disappointed. Bob D. East Setauket

Location

Welcome to Setauket Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers! Nestled along the scenic Route 25A in East Setauket, New York, this delightful deli stands as a cherished cornerstone of the local food scene. Known for its vibrant culinary offerings and exceptional service, Setauket Gourmet is a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors looking to savor delicious meals crafted with care.

Setauket Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers boasts a wide-ranging menu that caters to every palate. From their create-your-own sandwiches, like the finely sliced Bologna or classic ham and cheese, to hot entrees that include a comforting Chicken Parm served with mashed potatoes and roasted veggies, each dish is prepared with fresh ingredients and a touch of love. Don’t forget to try the rich Mac and Cheese, perfect for both kids and adults alike!

  • Family Dinner Packages: Hosting a gathering? Their family dinner packages, offering dishes like Chicken Francese with vegetable rice or Penne ala Vodka, are designed to please any crowd.
  • Outdoor Seating: Whether you’re dining alone or with friends, enjoy your meal in their cozy outdoor seating area while soaking in the pleasant ambiance.
  • Convenience: With options for delivery and takeout, Setauket Gourmet ensures you have access to quality food wherever you are. They also accept various payment methods including Apple Pay, making it as easy as pie to indulge in your favorite deli delights.

What sets Setauket Gourmet apart is not just the food, but the exemplary service as well. Customers rave about the attentive staff who go above and beyond to ensure a fantastic dining experience. One happy diner, Jules M., shared, “Great food and amazing service. Best egg sandwiches in town!!!” With such enthusiastic feedback, it’s clear that every bite resonates with quality and warmth.

Moreover, catering is one of their standout services, perfect for events large and small. Frances G. praised their catering, stating that the food was “delicious” and arrived right on time, highlighting their reliability and commitment to excellence. Event hosts can rest easy knowing that Setauket Gourmet will contribute to a successful gathering.

In conclusion, Setauket Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers is more than just a deli; it’s a community gem that reflects the essence of good food and even better service. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick sandwich, a hearty meal, or catering for a special occasion, you’re guaranteed to leave satisfied. Visit them at 216 Rt 25A, East Setauket, NY or give them a call at (631) 751-1200 to discover the delightful offerings that await you!